W.H. Taylor Shirtmakers

Bought an oxford button down in a blue stripe. It's a proper heavier weave than the fine poplin shirts I usually get, and the buttons feel sturdy. The sleeves came out a touch long on me so I'd size down a bit if you're between sizes. Good shirt, just needed a bit of guesswork.

Sadly I have to say the shirts aren't what they were a few years back. I've bought from them for well over a decade and the cotton used to feel a lot more substantial, but my last two have gone thin and the collars lose their shape after a couple of washes. The fit is still good and the ordering is simple enough, but for the price I expected better. I'll have a look elsewhere before I order again.

The first thing I noticed was how soft the cotton is, much nicer than I expected for a shirt at this price. The only small thing was the delivery took a day longer than the site said, but it still came well packed. I'd happily order again.

Compared with the shirts I used to pick up at the department store, these fit me a good deal better in the shoulders and the cuffs stay crisp. I've been ordering from them for years and nothing much has changed in a good way. Delivery has always been prompt, usually within the week.

Got the oxford shirt in light blue and it's honestly lovely, the material is nice and thick. Only thing is it took a while to arrive, like nearly two weeks, which was a bit annoying. Would still wear it though.

Bought the classic white oxford for a work dinner and it looked smart without costing a fortune. I've washed it several times and it still looks fresh. Good value for something I'll wear for years.

The collar stays put which is the main thing for me, I get through a lot of shirts and these last well through the wash. Ordered three on the site and they arrived in two days. Didn't have to pay extra for postage over the minimum either, which saved a bit. Not flashy but they do the job and I've stopped looking elsewhere for work shirts.

I used to buy from a shop in town, and compared with those these shirts feel a touch thinner through the body. The shoulders are a little narrow on me, though I expect that's my fault for not checking the measurements properly. Ordering was simple enough and the reply to my sizing question took a couple of days. They're perfectly respectable shirts, just not quite what I'd hoped.

Bought a classic white oxford shirt for my husband. It's well made and the stitching is neat, though I think it's a bit more than I'd pay for a plain shirt. The delivery took about four working days which was a little slow. He's happy with it so I suppose that's what matters.

Compared with the chain shirts I normally buy, these feel a bit nicer in the fabric but not by enough to justify the difference. The fit is decent and they look smart. Delivery was quick though, and the packaging was fine.

I needed a couple of smart shirts for work after my old ones gave up. Went for plain white and a light blue, and they've held up well through a dozen washes now. The price works out much cheaper per wear than the supermarket ones I was buying before. Checkout was quick and they arrived in a few days.

These are the ones I'd go back to. I looked at a few other online shirt makers first and the fit here was noticeably better in the shoulders. Not the cheapest, but the quality makes up for it.

Compared to the big high street chains these are miles better for the money. The collars actually hold their shape and the sleeves are the right length for me. Ordered on a Tuesday and it turned up Friday, nice and flat in a card box.

Looked at a few places first and these were a bit more than the supermarket versions but the cotton is noticeably heavier. The sizing guide on the site was helpful and the shirt fitted pretty much as expected. Delivery was quick, took about three days. Only small gripe is the price, but I'd still pick these again.

I would say these are the best shirts I have had in a long while. The collar sits nicely and the buttons have stayed firmly attached, which is more than I can say for some I've bought elsewhere. The site was straightforward to navigate and I found my size without any bother. I shall certainly be ordering again for my husband.

Needed a smart shirt for a few uni events and the site made it easy to find one. Arrived quicker than I thought and it's comfy enough to wear all day. Might get another in a different colour.

We needed a few crisp shirts for a family wedding and I'd used them before, so I went straight back. Ordering was easy and the sizing chart matched my measurements. One shirt arrived with a loose thread on the cuff, nothing major. They're still my go to for proper shirts.

Needed a shirt for a job interview on Monday and this turned up Thursday, so no complaints there. The fit is a bit boxy but honestly that's kind of the look. Good quality for the money and the checkout was quick on my phone.